Golriz Ghahraman's resignation raises questions about life in political spotlight
The Green MP resigned yesterday after facing allegations of shoplifting
Mōrena, and welcome to The Bulletin for Wednesday, January 17, written by Anna Rawhiti-Connell.
In today’s edition: NZ economy “unexpectedly” has “some wind in its sails”; road user charges for electric vehicles will apply from April 1; Trump beats rival in first state to choose Republican candidate; but first, Golriz Ghahraman’s resignation raises questions about nature of political life and the final report into electoral law reform lands
Green MP Golriz Ghahrama resigns after shoplifting allegations
Following allegations of shoplifting, Green MP Golriz Ghahraman resigned yesterday. As Stewart Sowman-Lund reports, the MP said her mental health had been “badly affected” by stresses related to her work, which had led her to “act in ways that are completely out of character”. She apologised and was clear in not wanting to excuse her actions but explain them. In a statement, Ghahraman said, “People should, rightly, expect the highest standards of behaviour from their elected representatives. I fell short. I’m sorry.” She has requested space and privacy. Green party co-leader James Shaw said yesterday that Ghahraman was subject to “pretty much continuous threats” during her time in parliament. These were sexual and violent in nature and included death threats. In 2019, it was reported that Ghahraman would be accompanied by a security guard following a series of death threats. Ghahraman revealed she was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis in 2020. Newshub’s Laura Walter looks back at her political career. The Herald’s Thomas Coughlan says her resignation will be a huge loss for the Greens, citing the expertise and advocacy Ghahraman brought to her portfolios — including foreign policy and electoral reform.
Questions raised again about the realities of political life
Once again, bearing bleak similarities to the circumstances that led to Kiri Allan’s resignation last year, questions have been raised about parliamentary culture and the normalisation of abusive and threatening behaviour directed at MPs. Professor Joanna Kidman, the director of He Whenua Taurikura/National Centre of Research Excellence for Preventing and Countering Violent Extremism said despite the reports that had been completed on Parliament’s workplace culture, it remains an adversarial environment, often without support for people who have been targeted.
This morning, Spinoff editor Mad Chapman writes, “As we watch brown woman after brown woman succumb to “the pressures of the job”, it’s worth remembering that not all MPs have the same pressures. If you’ve never worried about how your wider community might react to your work or the decisions you make, that’s one less pressure. If you’ve never ignored a casually racist or sexist or homophobic remark at your expense, that’s one less pressure. If you have always been confident that your bosses have your best interests at heart, that’s one less pressure.”
Shaun Robinson’s advice after Kiri Allan’s resignation on how to respond to a person’s actions in the context of their mental state also holds plenty of relevance in this situation. “Empathy and accountability can go hand in hand,’ he wrote. Emily Writes also reflects on our choices when responding to a very public “fall from grace”.
Former Wellington mayor to enter parliament
As the next person on the Green party list, former Wellington mayor Celia Wade-Brown will now enter parliament. The Spinoff’s Wellington editor, Joel MacManus, profiled Wade-Brown during last year’s election campaign. There are now two former mayors of Wellington in parliament this term, with Wade-Brown joining NZ First’s Andy Foster. Ghahraman’s resignation and Labour’s Ibrahim Omer’s loss in the Wellington Central seat means we no longer have any MPs in parliament who entered New Zealand as a refugee.
Government rejects four of expert panel’s recommendations on electoral reform
Ghahraman was the Green party’s electoral reform spokesperson, championing lowering the voting age to 16 and giving all prisoners the right to vote. Her Electoral Strengthening Democracy Amendment Bill was drawn from the biscuit tin in May 2022. It didn't make it past the first reading, largely superseded by the then government’s review into electoral law. The Independent Electoral Review released its final report yesterday (summary here) after delivering a draft in June last year. The panel, chaired by Deborah Hart, has over 140 made recommendations. The government has already rejected four of them, including lowering the voting age to 16, allowing all prisoners to vote and stand for parliament, freezing the ratio of electorate to list seats and repealing the offence of 'treating' voters with refreshments and entertainment. The recommendation to have a referendum on the length of a term of parliament is already being looked at by the government. Act leader David Seymour described the proposal to lower the voting age as a victory for the Greens and “Chairman Mao”. "Combine voting at 16 with civics delivered by left-wing teacher unionists and you've got a recipe for cultural revolution, pitting indoctrinated socialist youth against the parents and taxpayers who pay their bills," he said. As Newsroom’s Marc Daalder writes (paywalled), the review still leaves the issues surrounding how political campaigns are funded up for serious debate. “The report proposes something of a swap – parties would give up access to unlimited donations revenue in exchange for greater state funding,” he writes.
The Spinoff and SparkLab proudly present: Business is Boring Live
Right-sizing sustainability for different businesses.
Join host Simon Pound for a discussion with Spark Sustainability Director Leela Gantman and CEO of the Sustainable Business Network, Rachel Brown.
We'll be discussing the steps that businesses of different sizes can take to use technology and tools to track, mitigate and reduce their climate impact.
If you would like to join us, please RSVP: commercial@thespinoff.co.nz by the 26th January.
‘Wind in the sails’ of the economy
As interest.co.nz’s Dan Brunskill reports, headline business confidence jumped from a net -49% in December 2022 to -10% at the end of 2023, according to the latest survey by the New Zealand Institute of Economic Research. This sentiment contrasts somewhat with the GDP figures released in December, which showed the economy shrank 0.3% in the September quarter. Brunskill does note that business confidence tends to be higher under a National government. ANZ economists said the survey showed the New Zealand economy had “unexpectedly got some wind in its sails”. interest.co.nz’s David Hargreaves reports on the unusual move by the Reserve Bank (RBNZ) to “break its summer silence”, with chief economist Paul Conway making a keynote speech on January 30 that will address recent economic developments. Hargreaves notes its significance, saying the speech will follow the latest inflation figures released on January 24 and come before the first RBNZ set piece of the year, the Official Cash Rate (OCR) review on February 28. BusinessDesk’s Rebecca Howard writes (paywalled) that the speech could offer insight into the central bank’s plans for the OCR after it surprised markets late last year by saying it would hike rates again if necessary.
Road user charges for electric vehicles from April 1
Transport minister Simeon Brown has confirmed that electric vehicles (EVs) and plug-in hybrids will lose their long-time exemption from road user charges (RUCs) on April 1. This has been on the cards for a while. Former transport minister David Parker flagged it in August last year, and March 31 this year was set as the date the exemption would expire after it was extended in July 2021. As the Herald’s Chris Keall notes, if EVs maintained their RUC exemption as the country’s fleet electrifies, the Crown would be left with a $2b hole in its books. Keall also notes that EV registration figures show the heaviest concentrations of electric vehicles in Remuera and other top-earning suburbs.
Bus fares in Auckland will also rise by an average of 6.2% from February 4. The chief executive of Auckland Transport, Dean Kimpton, has told BusinessDesk’s Oliver Lewis (paywalled) that he believes the funding system for land transport in New Zealand is broken and needs urgent attention.
The Spinoff is powered by its supporters
In 2023, Spinoff readers funded some of our most beloved, well-read, impactful work. Help Me Hera, The Cost of Being, powerful longreads, Election 2023 coverage, laugh-out-loud satire, Auckland stories, Wellington stories, Christchurch stories and everything in between were powered by Spinoff members and donors. If you did support us, thank you from all of us at The Spinoff. If helping fund well-crafted and insightful journalism is on your list for 2024, donate today or sign up to become a Spinoff member.
Click and Collect
Donald Trump beats Republican rivals in Iowa, the first state to choose their Republican candidate
An explainer on the Iowa caucuses
Trump will be in court in New York today as the trial to determine how much he will pay in damages for defaming columnist E. Jean Carroll in 2019 statements by denying her rape allegations begins
Māori development minister Tama Potaka and chair of the Māori Affairs select committee, Dan Bidois, will represent the government at Kiingitanga hui on Saturday. Iwi leaders reject NZ First’s Shane Jones’ suggestion that hui could turn into a “monumental moan session”.
Elton John joins the EGOT club — all the best and worst moments from the Emmys
Endangered and at-risk lizards versus a thrill ride in Canterbury — Newsroom’s David Williams lays out the details of a case due to resume in the Environment Court early this year
Feeling clever? Click here to play 1Q, Aotearoa’s newest, shortest daily quiz.
Stewart Sowman-Lund does us all a favour and recaps ten domestic and eight international stories you may have missed over the summer. Sam Brookes reviews the new season of True Detective, returning to our screens after a five-year hiatus. Luke Owen Smith investigates the growing ‘bean-to-bar’ local chocolate maker scene. A junior civil servant explains how she lives frugally, with the occasional splurge for our Cost of Being series. Talisker Scott Hunter argues that ghosting unsuccessful job applicants can leave them feeling worthless.
Sporting snippets
The third T20 international between the Black Caps and Pakistan starts at 1pm in Dunedin today
For the first time in 28 years, the Black Sticks won’t be heading to the Olympics after failing to advance to the semifinals at the qualifying tournament in India.
New Zealand will host the first British & Irish Lions women’s tour in 2027
Former All Black Byron Kelleher in court in France over domestic violence accusation
Got some feedback about The Bulletin, or anything in the news? Get in touch with me at thebulletin@thespinoff.co.nz.
If you liked what you read today, share The Bulletin with friends, family and colleagues.
One does not have to go far, FB and twitter so see the abuse thrown at her, mostly from White National voting males, who never had amounted to much in their lives, might have a bit in the bank and see themselves as great business people, but the realty is, they have never achieved as much as she has. I am not a green voter, and at 71 years old have seen a bit and been a few places, and this is not a nice place any more, to many arseholes.
When did it ever become acceptable to base an argument on threats of personal physical and sexual violence? It seems the argument must be weak to resort to these tactics.
And when did the law allow such threatening language to occur?