Why the Greens aren’t booting Darleen Tana out of parliament (yet)
The rookie MP has resigned from the Greens, but hasn't clarified if she'll leave parliament too.
Mōrena, and welcome to The Bulletin for Tuesday, July 9.
In today’s edition: Siouxsie Wiles “vindicated” after court ruling, is Auckland on track for trackless trams, and will Christopher Luxon get to meet Joe Biden in Washington? But first, the Greens issue a direct message to outcast MP Darleen Tana: “Please resign”.
A drawn out demise for a new MP
The Greens have confirmed that one of its newest MPs has resigned under a cloud of suspicion, adding to an already difficult year for the party. Darleen Tana was only elected last year, but was suspended in mid-March after allegations of migrant exploitation first reported by Stuff’s Steve Kilgallon. If you don’t know much about Tana, that’s no surprise – she has spent more time on forced leave than as an MP during her time in politics: 116 days. Her name is now inextricably linked with a lengthy investigation and the taxpayer-funded pay packet she has been pocketing for the past four months while away from work. As pollster David Farrar wryly noted on Twitter, Tana’s time of absence has been longer than the Falklands War (74 days). The report into Tana’s alleged behaviour was released to the party co-leaders last Friday night, but has yet to be made public. However, reported Stuff, it’s believed to back up the damning claims raised in the media regarding Tana’s knowledge of allegations made against her husband and the operation of his Auckland bike shop.
How is Darleen Tana still an MP?
While Tana has resigned as a Green Party member, she has so far ignored calls from her former co-leaders to leave parliament entirely. For now, she’s still an MP and as Laura Walters writes for Newsroom Pro (paywalled), could be a thorn in the Greens’ side if she decides to stick around. In a statement last night, reported here by The Post, Tana gave no indication if she would leave parliament and instead criticised the report into her alleged behaviour.
That means that – at least for now – Tana remains an MP, just one without a caucus. “Please resign,” said co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick yesterday, admitting she had not been able to reach Tana ahead of an extraordinary press conference at parliament. “It is our very strong view that she misled myself and Marama [Davidson].” Later, on RNZ’s Checkpoint, Swarbrick went further: “if we can be straight up about it, it is our strong view that she lied to us”.
The Greens have been here before, most recently when Elizabeth Kerekere resigned over bullying claims in 2023. In that situation, Kerekere stayed on as an independent MP until the election. That’s because the Greens chose not to invoke the “party-hopping” law – the rule that allows party leaders to expel MPs from parliament if they leave the party during a term of parliament. Chris Hipkins also had the option to boot Meka Whaitiri from parliament when she announced her planned defection to Te Pāti Māori, as Toby Manhire reported for The Spinoff at the time, but again opted against this.
An added complication
Otago University law professor Andrew Geddis, writing this morning on The Spinoff, explains that despite being an option on the table, it’s incredibly unlikely to be used. Instead, parties instead tend to leave misbehaving MPs to languish in political Siberia at the back of the debating chamber. There’s an added complication for the Greens. While Swarbrick’s comments yesterday suggest the report into Tana’s alleged behaviour is very serious, the party has a long history of vocally opposing the party hopping rule. Former Green co-leader Jeanette Fitzsimons explained why on The Spinoff back in 2018, at the same time her ex-party was begrudgingly supporting it through parliament while in government with Labour. It would, as Politik’s Richard Harman (paywalled) argues, be highly hypocritical for the Greens to choose to invoke the law now – though Swarbrick said the party hadn’t yet discussed using it. Nobody likes being called a hypocrite, especially not members of parliament.
Strong words for serious allegations
Te Ao Māori News has a timeline of the Tana scandal, notable for its brevity: there were two complaints against the business owned by Tana’s husband in February and March, and then everything else has taken place behind closed doors until this week. Throughout this process, the Green Party co-leaders have expressed frustration at the time taken to investigate the claims, but also maintained that natural justice was critical. But yesterday, Swarbrick expressed upset at the findings of the report. “I am finding it really hard to reconcile somebody I thought I knew and loved with the behaviour that is outlined in this report,” she told reporters. “Darleen’s actions are completely at odds with our party’s values, policies and kaupapa.”
There are unanswered questions, reports Newsroom’s Marc Daalder, some of which may be clarified when the report (or parts of it) is released in the future. The workers at the centre of the claims are, reports RNZ’s Soumya Bhamidipati, focused on getting owed wages rather than on whether Tana leaves parliament.
For the Greens, this latest departure caps what has been a rocky few months. The Tana claims followed the Golriz Ghahraman shoplifting scandal and the bullying allegations against Kerekere last year. Then, in May, Julie Anne Genter faced complaints over “threatening behaviour” against National’s Matt Doocey in parliament. James Shaw, the long-serving and steady co-leader, also opted to leave parliament this year (though this was widely predicted and not linked to any scandal). You may expect the cumulative impact of these incidents to dent the Greens’ reputation, but the polls tell a different story. As Newsroom’s Laura Walters observes, the party is steady at around 13 or 14%, while Swarbrick routinely crops up as a preferred prime minister.
Like what you read? Become a member!
Every contribution exclusively funds our journalism and helps keep it freely available to all. Join up today!
Already a member? Ka nui te mihi, your support means the world to us.
Siouxsie Wiles ‘vindicated’ after Employment Court ruling
The Employment Court has ruled that Auckland University breached its contractual obligations to protect the health and safety of microbiologist Siouxsie Wiles, ordering she be compensated $20,000. RNZ has a good summary of the court’s findings, reporting that the university promoted Wiles’ work during the Covid-19 pandemic but failed to protect her from a “negative backlash” she experienced during the pandemic. The court’s decision follows a lengthy hearing at the end of last year, which I reported on at the time. Wiles told the court she felt threatened, stressed and harassed by the behaviour of online extremists, and claimed that while the “threats, harassment and abuse as a result of doing [her] work [had] been awful enough, the response from the university [had] been worse”.
Wiles told the Herald she felt “absolutely vindicated” by the court’s decision. “It’s a real win on the principles of what this case was being fought on so I feel very vindicated.” The court did not agree with Wiles’ claim that her academic freedom had been curtailed by the university’s actions.
Trackless trams for Auckland?
There have been a lot of proposed transport options put forward for Auckland over the years, the latest being trackless trams. The Herald’s Simon Wilson writes (paywalled) that one of these will be trialled in Auckland before the end of the year – “probably” – with manufacturer China Rail prepared to ship a unit over at the company’s own expense. If, like Newstalk ZB’s Ryan Bridge questioned earlier this morning, you think a “trackless tram” is just a bus – well, it’s not quite the same. Wilson writes: “the units are guided by magnetic nails driven into the road”.
Meanwhile, Wilson’s colleague Bernard Orsman has reported (paywalled) on the total cost of Labour’s failed plans for light rail in Auckland: a hefty $229m over six years.
Discover By The Bottle: New Zealand’s leading boutique wine retailer
By The Bottle is a celebrated indie beverage retailer. They showcase a huge range of wine, beer, small batch spirits and zero percent beverages from local and international artisans. They've got organic, biodynamic and sustainably produced drops. Shop online with nationwide shipping or pop into their Mount Eden shop. Click here to explore By The Bottle's collection. (sponsored)
Click and Collect
A full Oval Office meet and greet between Christopher Luxon and Joe Biden is unlikely, but the pair could still meet on the outskirts of Nato. As the Herald’s Claire Trevett writes, Luxon will still secure meetings with high profile US lawmakers.
NZTA debt projected to increase to $7.6 billion, reports Oliver Lewis for BusinessDesk (paywalled).
Investigation into Waipareira political donations referred to Charities Registration Board.
If you’re a bit confused about the French elections, I recommend this chat between The Spinoff’s Toby Manhire and UK-based journalist Henry Cooke.
In sport, New Zealander Lulu Sun’s unexpected grand slam rise is lighting up Wimbledon. From 2019, here’s an episode of The Spinoff’s Scratched looking at Ruia Morrison, the Māori tennis star who made it to Wimbledon.
With fake news, AI slop and little human connection, Anna Rawhiti-Connell wonders what's going on at Facebook these days. Relatedly, Duncan Greive explains why the big tech bargaining bill is not about Google. Shanti Mathias talks to fans of stripy polyprop, with the garish warm layers disappearing and being replaced by plain merino. Duncan Greive remembers what living in a cheap shoebox apartment meant to him in his early twenties. Plus, here's all the new movies and TV on streaming services this week.
What you should be reading
The Spinoff’s Shanti Mathias picks some must reads for the week.
This review of Christine Blasely Ford's new book considers what happens when a woman comes forward with allegations of sexual abuse – and a high-profile man faces no consequences
Anyone who has tried to stack a dishwasher efficiently might enjoy this fascinating story about how mathematicians tried to figure out the most inefficient shape to pack into small spaces.
Did you know that lots of women's sporting codes were created after women started beating men? As the debate over trans people in sport rages on, to almost no-one's benefit, it's a good reminder.
Used the term “tea” with no idea of it's origins? How social media flattens slang.
That’s it for The Bulletin today, thanks for reading. I’ll be back tomorrow morning.
Let me know in the comments, or get in touch with me at thebulletin@thespinoff.co.nz, if you have any feedback on today’s issue or anything in the news.
If you liked what you read today, share The Bulletin with friends, family and colleagues.