The road to driver drug testing is paved with complexities
The government wants 50,000 roadside drug tests carried out every year. Haven't we been here before?
Mōrena, and welcome to The Bulletin for Monday, August 19.
In today’s edition: Jacinda Ardern will speak on a panel at the Democratic National Convention in Chicago, political leaders from across the spectrum are descending on Tūrangawaewae Marae and the new chief human rights commissioner rejects accusations of transphobia. But first, police have been tasked with upping the number of roadside drink and drug tests.
Bolstering the testing regime
The government has announced a crackdown on drink and drug drivers, following through on an election pledge to see thousands more roadside tests carried out each year. It’s part of the Road Policing Investment Programme, which confirmed $1.3 billion for road policing over the next three years. The Herald’s Thomas Coughlan explained the key details, reporting that police will be tasked with performing 3.3m roadside alcohol tests and 50,000 roadside drug tests. To put those figures in context, while 3.2m alcohol tests were carried out last year, that’s actually an outlier. This chart compiled from police data and shared on Twitter shows that the number of alcohol breath tests dropped as low as 1.4m in 2018 (and again in 2020, though the country was under Covid restrictions for part of that year).
Ministry of Transport figures, meanwhile, show that the number of deaths caused by drunk or drugged drivers has been trending up, save for another dip during the Covid years.
The road to bringing in drug testing
Introducing roadside drug testing was a key pledge of National’s election campaign, though it’s been on the agenda for several years. In the run up to 2020’s cannabis referendum, which ultimately failed, there was a heightened focus on the impacts of drug driving. In 2019, reported Zane Small for Newshub, the then-Labour government sought public input on how to improve the drug testing regime. Several complexities were identified, such as that the tests cannot determine if a driver is actually impaired, like with alcohol breath testing. While Labour passed legislation in 2022 that would have allowed for random roadside drug testing, another roadblock was encountered when it was determined that a device capable of accurately recording results did not exist. A subsequent law change introduced a lab test to back up the roadside test, which Newsroom’s Emma Hatton described as a “workaround”. Earlier this year, former police minister Ginny Andersen defended her government’s work in the face of criticism from the current government, reported RNZ.
There are risks
Simeon Brown said yesterday he expected police to conduct 50,000 “oral fluid tests” during the first year of the new drug testing regime. That’s the same technology used in Australia and is permissible under the coalition’s updated legislation. Under the proposed law, anyone who failed two roadside drug tests would be suspended from driving for 12 hours and could face further penalties. An oral fluid sample would be sent for more sophisticated laboratory testing. But some have expressed concern that it could mean unfair penalisation. Maki Herbert, the co-leader of the Aotearoa Legalise Cannabis Party, told Te Ao Māori News she’s worried that people using cannabis medicinally, or using certain anti-depressants that stay in the system for several days, could end up in the justice system as a result. She also questioned whether Māori could be unfairly targeted given they disproportionately make up criminal justice statistics. The Drug Foundation has previously expressed concern around people being unwittingly caught up by drug testing, reported RNZ’s Anneke Smith, noting that some medicinal cannabis users may not actually be impaired but could still report a positive result. In Australia, where roadside drug testing has existed in some states for two decades, an Adelaide man had his license cancelled earlier this year after a false positive claimed he had methamphetamine in his system, the ABC reported.
The road to zero?
The clampdown on drug and drunk drivers is part of a broader roading strategy by the coalition, though some have questioned whether all parts of that strategy are aligned. Earlier this year, as Newsroom’s Emma Hatton reported, the government scrapped the Road to Zero safety plan introduced by Labour. That plan targeted a 40% reduction in deaths and serious injuries on the roads from 2018 levels by 2030. It faced public and political scrutiny and the former government itself cooled on parts of the plan, Hatton reported. One part of that programme had involved widespread road speed reductions which the coalition has since made moves to reduce, angering road safety advocates. In a post in July, advocacy group Greater Auckland argued that the reversal of speed limit reductions would “cost lives” – the exact thing the government is aiming to stop by clamping down on drug and drunk drivers.
Show your support, join up today!
"As a New Zealander living in Sydney, The Spinoff helps me to feel in touch with what's happening back home. There's a great breadth to the content – and the enthusiasm from your contributors is palpable. I feel happy and proud to be a member." Ian, Sydney.
Whether living here or abroad, if you value our work please show your support by becoming a member today.
McKee says time as gun lobbyist was about advocating for firearms safety
Associate justice minister Nicole McKee has defended her past career as a gun lobbyist in a wide-ranging interview with Jack Tame on Q+A. As we discussed last week, McKee is facing scrutiny over her role in the government’s firearms reforms given her former job working for the Council of Licenced Firearms Owners. McKee said her advocacy had always been around safe use of firearms and it was “really important that we do have somebody that has an understanding about firearms use across all the different disciplines that we have”. Those who don’t own or use firearms would be safer if the laws were “fit for purpose”, she added. The government’s sweeping reforms include a review of the gun registry and transferring the Firearms Safety Authority from the police to another Government department. There will also be a substantive rewrite of the 40-year-old Arms Act.
Jacinda Ardern to speak on panel at Democrat convention
Former prime minister Jacinda Ardern is heading to Chicago to attend the Democratic National Convention and speak on a panel, Stuff’s Glenn McConnell reported. The four-day event will see Democrats rally behind vice-president Kamala Harris, who will formally accept her nomination to run for the top job in November’s election. Ardern won’t be speaking on the main stage – that’s reserved for a who’s who of high profile Democrats such as Barack Obama and current president Joe Biden. However, she will join a panel on Wednesday morning NZT called “Healing the Nation”. It makes her the first New Zealand prime minister to speak at the convention.
Take part in The Spinoff survey for a chance to win one of three $400 Prezzy Cards!
Your feedback is crucial to us, and as an independent media company, we're committed to making your experience even better. The survey is quick, anonymous, and we’ll only use your email for the prize draw. Don’t miss out—click here to have your say and enter the draw!
Click and Collect
Political leaders from across the spectrum are descending on Tūrangawaewae Marae in Ngāruawāhia. Act, however, will not be present.
I enjoyed this Audrey Young profile of education minister Erica Stanford (paywalled), who has undoubtedly been one of the strongest performers in the coalition cabinet.
The Spinoff’s Madeleine Chapman asks: Can you be a human rights commissioner and transphobic at the same time? The new commissioner, Stephen Rainbow, tells Stuff he isn’t transphobic.
The New Zealand and Australia prime ministers say they are “in lockstep like never before”, but the issue of deportees remains a thorn in the side of the trans-Tasman relationship.
Amelia Wade reveals in the Sunday Star-Times that no more mental health beds have been added since the new government took power despite National being critical of their predecessors doing the same.
You might think your ham is from New Zealand, but as Shanti Mathias explains, it’s likely imported from a country with lower standards of animal welfare. The decision to downsize Whaikaha has outraged disabled people who fought for decades for a ministry of their own, writes Robyn Hunt. In a special edition of My Life in TV, we take a stroll down memory lane with the co-hosts of the new season of Celebrity Treasure Island. For The Spinoff Essay, Caroline Shepherd watched all 46 of Tom Cruise’s films over the past 12 months. Why? And with an extradition order now signed off, Shanti Mathias shares a timeline of the Kim Dotcom saga.
That’s it for this morning, thanks for reading. I’ll be back tomorrow.
Want to get in touch? Join the conversation in the Substack comments section or via email at thebulletin@thespinoff.co.nz if you have any feedback on today’s top stories (or anything else in the news).
If you liked what you read today, share The Bulletin with friends, family and colleagues.
They failed to stop ram raids. They tried to stop boy racers, and failed. They failed to try and stop gang activity. Now they try to fail to stop drug driving by raising the speed limit and pushing cops out of a job.
I bet you they will reintroduce Land Transport Officers to police the roads and leave cops to seperate Maori kids from their families.
I'm wondering where the increased capacity for Police to do all this is going to come from. More drug testing, more alcohol testing, wipe out the gangs, stop boy racers etc etc, but no mention of extra funding. Ministers give these impossible politicised targets instead of leaving policing to the people who know what they're talking about.