The 'fake news' article that risks harming New Zealand's global reputation
Foreign minister Winston Peters has demanded a correction.
Mōrena, and welcome to The Bulletin for Monday, February 3.
In today’s edition: Wayne Brown poised to confirm second tilt at Auckland mayoralty, Manurewa Marae investigation report delayed at the last minute, and Act leader David Seymour denies wrongdoing over Tim Jago allegations. But first, the US senator accused of interfering in New Zealand’s domestic affairs.
‘Unfairly affecting New Zealand’s reputation’
New Zealand’s embassy in Washington DC has been brought in to try and stem the fallout from a “fake news” article shared online by a high profile US senator. The Herald’s Jamie Ensor reported that the article, by Israeli newspaper Haaretz, claimed that Israelis applying for a visa to enter New Zealand must declare any service in the Israeli Defence Force. It picked up traction over the weekend after Republican senator Ted Cruz, a former presidential hopeful with over six million followers on Twitter, shared the article. However, Immigration NZ said the article’s claims were incorrect and the agency was seeking “an urgent correction” to the article. “We have sought an urgent update to the article as it is unfairly affecting New Zealand’s reputation,” said the agency’s deputy chief operating officer Jeannie Melville. Immigration NZ said no new policies for Israeli or Palestinian nationals had been announced, and Israelis wishing to stay in New Zealand for less than three months don’t need a visa – just an electronic travel declaration.
‘Fake news’
In his remarks on social media, reported The Post, Cruz said it was “difficult to treat New Zealand as a normal ally within the American alliance system, when they denigrate and punish Israeli citizens for defending themselves”. It prompted responses online from three senior government ministers, including foreign minister Winston Peters who labelled the story “fake news” and demanded a correction. “Israelis do not need visitor visas to travel to New Zealand, let alone have to declare their military service,” Peters said in a tweet. Cruz’s tweet remains online at the time of publication, though the post by the news outlet has been removed from social media. Its story, however, remains visible on its own website. A follow-up report included comments from Immigration NZ.
Others to weigh in include Act leader David Seymour and defence minister Judith Collins, with the former telling Stuff it was "unfortunate that someone on the other side of the world got confused between John Minto and an actual leader". That’s a reference to a “genocide hotline” being promoted by Minto, a pro-Palestinian advocate, that gained attention last week and was condemned by both the government and the Human Rights Commissioner.
Interference from a major superpower
Immigration NZ said the incorrect information regarding New Zealand’s position on Israeli migrants was impacting our international reputation. It has also raised concerns about the relationship between the United States and Aotearoa at a time of heightened tensions following the inauguration of president Donald Trump. During a visit to Washington DC last year, PM Christopher Luxon met with lawmakers from across the political spectrum, Ted Cruz among them. At the time, Luxon batted away questions about whether he was courting politicians that could be influential under a Trump presidency. “Senators and committees in the system are really powerful, really influential and it’s really important to have direct relationships with them,” he said at the time, the Herald’s Claire Trevett reported.
Speaking to ThreeNews, international relations expert Robert Patman expressed frustration that incorrect information was being circulated by a high profile US politician. “It’s an extraordinary incident and it constitutes quite serious interference in New Zealand’s domestic affairs,” Patman said. “It’s very disappointing that a senior Republican member of the senate… has actually made such insubstantial claims.”
Trade war sparked after Trump tariffs
Local officials will be hoping to maintain a positive working relationship with the United States. Over the weekend, reported the BBC, president Donald Trump followed through on his promise to introduce new tariffs on neighbouring Mexico and Canada, along with China. The following day, reported CNN, Trump acknowledged that Americans may face some “pain” as a result of his actions, with both Canada and Mexico already moving to retaliate. Canada’s prime minister Justin Trudeau said he had been trying to speak with Trump since his inauguration but still still not made contact. "We don't want to be here, we didn't ask for this," Trudeau said at a press conference. Other countries, New Zealand included, are likely to be caught up in Trump’s plans for sweeping tariffs. Finance minister Nicola Willis told Bloomberg last year that we should be exempt. “Our starting position is please don’t do that,” Willis said in December. “The job that we’ve tasked our diplomats with is to put New Zealand’s absolute best foot forward.”
Have thoughts? Join the conversation in the comments.
We still need your help
Our extensive coverage of Waitangi 2025 is powered by the nearly 16,000 people who give to us on a monthly or annual basis or who have donated on a one-off basis. It was unimaginable before so many of you met our honesty with your generosity after our open letter in November.
We still need 4,500 new members to join us this year to ensure our future and continue the comprehensive, rigorous and thoughtful coverage of the things that matter to our audiences.
Please, if you value comprehensive coverage of Waitangi and Te Tiriti and you're not a member yet, make this week the week you sign up.
Manurewa Marae investigation report delayed at the last minute
The findings of a long-running inquiry into misuse of data allegations at Manurewa Marae were set to be made public this morning until an abrupt U-turn, reported the Herald’s Jamie Ensor. Media were alerted on Friday that the Public Service Commission would reveal the outcome of the investigation at a press conference in Wellington today. Then, just a few hours later, a second email confirmed this had been postponed. “The inquiry has been complex, involving six agencies, third-party service providers and findings that will impact all of the public service. Some matters will also require referral to other authorities for further consideration,” the statement said.
More reading:
Inquiry into marae data use raises concerns requiring investigation (Stuff)
Stats NZ inquiry clears Whānau Ora of 2023 Census data breach (NZ Herald)
Wayne Brown poised to confirm second tilt at mayoralty
Auckland mayor Wayne Brown hasn’t formally confirmed he’ll stand again at this year’s local elections, though it appears an announcement is coming in the days ahead. The Sunday Star-Times’ Jonathan Killick reported Brown felt compelled to stay on for a second term to ensure his reforms of council-controlled organisations were properly bedded in, according to a source. It was reported last week that Brown’s deputy, Desley Simpson, could run against the mayor after a campaign website was discovered. Simpson has downplayed this, saying a family member registered the domain name “for a laugh” and Brown is said not to be worried about the potential challenge.
More reading:
Wayne Brown set to seek a second term with polls showing he’s become a hit with voters (NZ Herald Premium, paywalled)
Browny’s pool was a gamble and it’s paid off (The Spinoff)
Join us live in 2025
We have four fantastic live events in 2025. Join us in Auckland and Wellington for The Spinoff Live!
Auckland at Q Theatre: Bryn & Ku’s Singles Club Party, February 13 and Gone by Lunchtime Live, April 9.
Wellington at the Hannah Playhouse: The Fold Live, February 20 and The Spinoff Book Club, March 13.
What did the Māori chiefs say before the signing of the Treaty of Waitangi in 1840?
Kicking off our week-long coverage of Waitangi Day 2025, The Spinoff’s Joel MacManus scours the archives to explain what was said by some of those who actually signed the Treaty in February 6, 1840.
To support work like this, consider becoming a Spinoff Member.
Click and Collect
Number of threats against politicians nosedives in coalition Government’s first year – so what’s changed?
Act leader David Seymour denies wrongdoing over Tim Jago allegations.
The government will wait a year before considering advice from the Covid-19 Royal Commission, reports Marc Daalder for Newsroom Pro (paywalled).
Green co-leader Marama Davidson marks her return to work this week, eight months after a breast cancer diagnosis.
Would-be Wellington mayor has a secret buyer and a hit list.
For BusinessDesk subscribers, Oliver Lewis reports that the company tasked with procuring new Interislander ferries still hasn’t been established (paywalled).
Each of the government’s various economic growth policy announcements asks something, in some way, of Queenstown. But it may not have the answer the government – and the rest of the country – wants, writes Victoria Crockford. For The Spinoff Essay, David Hill introduces us to “bus bloke” Murray: Pugnacious and genial, monosyllabic yet capable of gloriously subversive narratives, battered by life but proud as a peacock. Tara Ward reports from Dunedin as the health minister confirms a new hospital will indeed be built in the city. Alex Casey spends the afternoon on New Brighton beach with kite-flying YouTuber Jim Nicholls. Comedian Eli Matthewson takes us through his life in television.
That’s it for today, thanks for reading. Catch you back here tomorrow morning.
Want to get in touch? Join the conversation in the Substack comments section below or via email at thebulletin@thespinoff.co.nz if you have any feedback on today’s top stories (or anything else in the news).
If you liked what you read today, share The Bulletin with friends, family and colleagues.
Yes, the government's acceptance of Israel's genocide, ethnic cleansing and apartheid must be defended on the world stage.
Honestly, given everything that has happened over the last 15 months, perhaps we should be declining visas to active and reserve members of the IDF? Our government has done almost nothing to hold them accountable besides endorsing a handful of UN motions