Dramatic drop in people worried about law and order as youth crime figures soar. Why?
New polling shows a significant drop in people saying law and order is a top concern. Perception might be reality.
Mōrena, and welcome to The Bulletin for Wednesday, March 20, written by Anna Rawhiti-Connell.
In today’s edition: disabled people and their families appalled by sudden disability support funding restrictions; clarification on Peters’ Nazi comments, tubthumping and tax cuts; government makes accidental law change permanent; but first, crime figures for 2023, a justice system under pressure and polling that shows how concerned we are about law and order
Concern about law and order drops to lowest levels since May 2022
It was political strategist Lee Atwater who said, “Perception is reality”. Atwater worked as a Republican political operative with Bush and Reagan. The phrase is particularly cynical in a political context, and the mildest thing you might read about Atwater is that “he displayed more than a tinge of amorality.” He is not the topic of discussion today, but his words came to mind yesterday when looking over the latest Ipsos Issues Monitor results and a couple of crime and justice stories yesterday. The Ipsos results show crime/law & order has “significantly fallen in prominence as an issue” to be the fourth highest issue New Zealanders are concerned about at 27%, its lowest level since May 2022. It’s been number two since May 2023, peaking at 40%, which was its fourth consecutive high since the Ipsos Monitor began in 2018. It was sitting at 16% in February 2021. Toby Manhire zeroed in on the Ipsos survey results in June last year, and this is no rocket science from me, but you can view it as a pretty good precursor to what played out at the election.
Gap widens between National and Labour on handling issue
Overall, while the Ipsos polling gives National comfort on how people view its law and order credentials, the government’s performance was rated 4.6, which is just a bit above the 4.5 given to the last government before the election. The Ipsos polling is particularly useful in evaluating people’s perception of which party is best equipped to handle particular issues. “Tough on crime” is traditional National territory, and the party has consistently come out on top for law and order since February 2022. The gap between them and Labour was previously at its widest in recent times in August 2023, with 16 points between the two. There are now 22 points between the two parties. Labour was accused of not taking people's concerns seriously last year, and there was a late-breaking move to introduce a law specific to ram raids, which is now at the Select Committee stage. It’s not popular with legal experts and those who work with youth offenders and was deemed inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act last year by then-Attorney General David Parker. Andrew Geddis mentions a suggestion from a legal academic that a similar conclusion in the context of the gang patch ban legislation might represent a “‘badge of honour’ in that it announces to the world that the government is really serious about cracking down (or similar rhetoric).”
Continuing upward trend in sexual and violent crime data
What of actual crime statistics? As incredibly well explained by Chris Knox and Michael Neilson last year for the Herald (paywalled), this is complicated territory. The Herald’s Derek Cheng reported yesterday that the latest crime statistics show a spike in the number of robberies, burglaries and theft by children or young people, continuing an upward trend in youth crime since 2021. Cheng is also regularly circumspect about crime statistics, noting yesterday’s release of data from the Ministry of Justice “does not necessarily show whether actual crime is rising or falling” but “looking at the data over time can indicate trends” and “overall there is a continuing upward trend in sexual and violent crime data - including family violence.” The Ipsos polling period is only a week in late February, and the crime data is for the year ending December 2023, but unless we all observed a dramatic and unproven drop in crime in January and February, perception about the party best equipped to handle the issue and concerted moves to demonstrate action, no matter the questions about their real efficacy, are probably playing a role in reducing our levels of concern about crime.
Justice system under pressure as warning issued over backroom hiring freeze for police
A second story from Derek Cheng yesterday on the briefing from the Chief Justice (paywalled) to Attorney-General Judith Collins reveals a justice system still under immense pressure, a story that’s been running for quite some time. Cheng writes that Dame Helen Winkelmann’s briefing “paints a bleak picture of the challenges to properly resource the judiciary.” The justice sector, including the courts, is operating under the same directive from the government as the rest of the public service and needs to find 6.5% in savings. Winkelmann had asked for the courts, as “essential front-line services”, to be exempt. This morning The Herald is reporting that the Police Association, currently at loggerheads with the government over pay negotiations, is warning that a hiring freeze on backroom staff is “already causing backlogs and delays and will make it harder for the Government to implement its ‘tough on crime’ policy agenda.”
Right now, we need your support more than ever
The Spinoff has estimated that the number of full-time journalists in New Zealand may have halved since 2018 Census data was published. As the media landscape continues to change, The Spinoff is not immune to the drastic advertising slowdown impacting the viability of media in this country. To those who already support us, thank you. If you don’t and are able, we’d be very grateful if you’d consider becoming a Spinoff member or donating today.
Duncan Greive
Founder
Restrictions on support funding for disabled people blindside families
As The Herald’s Issac Davidson reports, an announcement from Whaikaha, the Ministry of Disabled People, on Monday has “appalled” disabled people and their families. The ministry, which commissions support services for around 50,000 people and funds equipment for around 100,000, announced changes to what disabled people could purchase with their funding. As Davidson writes, families have been blindsided by the changes, which are likely to limit their ability to hire a carer when seeking respite care with accommodation, travel and food costs for carers removed. As Newsroom's Emma Hatton reports, disability issues minister Penny Simmonds has called the change “a pause”, saying the ministry was “days” away from spending all its money. More on this on The Spinoff later this morning.
Tubthumping and tax cuts
There hasn’t been this much action in the wake of blasting Chumbawumba’s Tubthumping since it used to play near closing time at the Outback in Hamilton. Following deputy prime minister and foreign minister Winston Peters’ state of the nation speech on Sunday and his use of Tubthumping at the event, the Spinoff’s Gabi Lardies checked in with the band, who, during their time, were openly anarcho-communists. Unsurprisingly, they weren’t delighted by the use of the song. Peters hit back at our coverage, but as Stuff’s Tova O’Brien reports, Sony is going to issue a cease and desist notice on behalf of the band. Dovetailing into all of this is ongoing consternation from Peters about what he views as a misinterpretation of his Nazi Germany comments and co-governance. Jenna Lynch did an outstanding job piecing the timeline together last night for Newshub, which I am grateful for after hitting “a beyond The Bulletin” word limit” in my attempt. Perhaps most pertinent is a question asked of Peters after the speech. Asked by Newshub if his comparison of co-governance to Nazi Germany was appropriate, Peters said: “Yes, it is.”
Coming back to yesterday’s lead, prime minister Christopher Luxon did a round of morning media yesterday to clarify confusion caused by his post-cab comments, telling Mike Hosking on Newstalk that there weren’t going to be any new taxes in the Budget and that tax relief will happen.
Watch now: Meet three Pacific K-pop fans
Directed by Litia Tuiburelevu, K-POLYS is a one-off documentary that presents intimate portraits of three Polynesian K-pop fans: Boba, Ethan, and Ashley. All three are part of the K-pop fan community in Tāmaki Makaurau. It’s one of many that have sprung up worldwide as K-pop has gone from a musical genre in South Korea to a global cultural phenomenon. Watch now on The Spinoff.
Made with the support of NZ On Air.
Click and Collect
Owners of plug-in hybrids will pay less in road user charges after a change of heart by the government (and a change proposed by Labour and the Greens and subsequently voted through)
Labour concedes it could have done more to deal with disruptive state housing tenants
Grant Robertson will deliver his valedictory speech today - the Herald rounds up some of his best “roasts”
We’re no longer debating whether Wellington has lost its cool or its mojo but its “swagger”. All I know is swagger is definitely one of those words that takes on an odd quality if you read it too many times.
No swagger debates in Canterbury, just a simple request for more frequent - and faster - public transport options
Feeling clever? Click here to play 1Q, Aotearoa’s newest, shortest daily quiz.
Shanti Mathias investigates what happens to food supply in a disaster and finds it won’t be the supermarkets that save us in the next one. Stewart Sowman-Lund asks a few economists how Luxon's promised tax relief will be funded. Brannavan Gnanalingam reviews the 'undoubtedly brilliant' novel AMMA. Zoe Taptiklis-Haymes and Kelly Davenport say that a long-running Wellington music festival is too focused on the Jim Beam-ness and not enough on the Homegrown-ness. Two Auckland teachers in debt from a failed business explain how they’re making ‘frugal mode’ work for the Cost of Being.
The Bulletin is looking for a sponsor
Expertly curated, The Bulletin delivers essential news and diverse perspectives from Aotearoa and beyond to business leaders, politicians, and decision-makers nationwide. Contact commercial@thespinoff.co.nz to learn more.
Got some feedback about The Bulletin, or anything in the news? Get in touch with me at thebulletin@thespinoff.co.nz.
If you liked what you read today, share The Bulletin with friends, family and colleagues.
Because the media beat-up bankrolled by business interests, local and otherwise, has ceased. Meanwhile, as the article makes clear, there is little or no difference in citizen safety.
Swagger, the cringe is strong there Nicola, just sayin