Borrowing from your future to pay your rent costs today
National's new policy would allow under-30s to use their Kiwisaver to pay their bonds. Robbing pensioner Pete to pay propertyless Paul or pragmatic youth-driven policy during a cost-of-living crisis?
Mōrena and welcome to The Bulletin for Tuesday, July 18, by Anna Rawhiti-Connell. Presented in partnership with Z Energy.
In today’s edition: Labour begins week of law and order policy announcements as new poll puts National and Act in governing position; Gloriavale School under review; a new indepth profile of the prime minister featuring his Mum; but first, experts concerned about Kiweisver being used by politicians “as a ‘little pot of gold’ that could be used to tackle specific problems”
As rents rise, so do bonds
In the late 90s, you could punch some numbers into a telephone and draw down student loan living costs, the minimum amount being $400. Without my parent's knowledge (I was over 18), I would irresponsibly bolster my bank balances ahead of weekends. I have remained full of regret and slightly bitter about that empowerment ever since. Student loans didn’t become completely interest-free until 2006 so I well and truly paid for my tabs at bars across Dunedin. I’m not bitter about the introduction of interest-free student loans after I graduated but I’m just not sure I fully understood what interest was at that age. My financially illiterate decisions would follow me, albeit eventually interest-free, for nearly 20 years. Nowadays, living costs are paid out in weekly allocations, bar a course-related costs allowance. I usually paid about two weeks' rent in bond as a young person which came to a grand total of $130. Nowadays it's common for bond to be four weeks' rent. Trade Me's Rental Price Index shows New Zealand's median weekly rental price rose to $610 for May. Young people looking to contribute to what could be a $2,500 bond for a flat as rents continue to rise could be forgiven for wanting to dip into their KiwiSaver to cover that cost.
New National policy came from Young Nats
A new policy announced by the National party yesterday, developed by the Young Nats, would allow people under the age of 30 to dip into their Kiwisaver to pay for their bond. The money would be transferred from KiwiSaver directly to Tenancy Services and returned to their savings when the tenancy ended, provided they can get their bonds back. You can review some of the issues renters have had with getting bonds back, including quibbles over fluff in the lint tray of the washing machine, in Toby Morris’s Side Eye for September 2022. Tenants would be able to use their KiwiSaver to cover their rental bond for up to five years.
The policy comes with a financial penalty
New research published yesterday by Research NZ shows those aged 18-34 are feeling the cost of living squeeze more than any other age group so you could argue there’s an element of sticking-plaster pragmatism about this. However, while students aren’t being penalised with interest costs on their student loans as I was, there is still a financial penalty to this policy. Any money sitting with the Tenancy Tribunal is not sitting in a Kiwisaver account earning a return and it’s those without financial support from parents or savings who will be most likely to need help with bond payment. Factor in the 25% gender gap in KiwiSaver balances, which is most pronounced in the 18 to 25-year-old and 31 to 35-year-old age brackets, and you could argue it’s financially disadvantaged young women who would bear the biggest financial penalty for the costs of putting a roof over their heads.
Experts ‘hate it’
That’s how interest.co.nz’s Dan Brunskill’s piece on the policy is headlined. David Boyle, head of sales and marketing at Mint Asset Management, said he was concerned that politicians saw Kiwisaver as a “little pot of gold” that could be used to tackle specific problems. This morning, BusinessDesk’s investment editor and host of the “Cooking the Books” podcast, Frances Cook writes (paywalled) that “Using KiwiSaver for rental bonds is the most financially irresponsible thing” she’s heard in years. “Allowing people to take money out of their KiwiSaver when they’re young is exactly the opposite of what financial advisers would tell you to do. I constantly tell people that when you’re young and broke is the perfect time to invest. That’s because you have time on your side, so a little bit of money can go much further,” she writes.
If you're enjoying The Bulletin and value what we do, please consider joining The Spinoff Members
It’s because of our members that our small team of journalists are able to cover stories the length and breadth of New Zealand and tell them in an engaging and compelling way. Every dollar donated exclusively funds our journalism and ensures we can tackle topics important to us and readers like yourself. Tautoko mai, join today.
Labour announces first law and order policy as new polling puts National and Act in governing position
Yesterday prime minister Chris Hipkins announced what’s understood to be the first of three law and order policies expected this week. It includes laws being passed to try to add new aggravating factors to sentences for adults who encouraged young people to commit crimes, and the same for people posting their crimes on social media. While it was a government announcement, there is little time left for legislative amendments before the election, so this ostensibly doubles as election policy. The National Party proposed something similar a fortnight ago. Stuff’s Luke Malpass writes that the policy is a “very belated admission of just how much of an Achilles heel law and order has become for Labour.” Last night’s 1 News/Verian poll puts National, with the support of the Act Party, in a position to govern. Just. Toby Manhire has compiled this new polling snapshot with last night’s results included.
Gloriavale School under review
The Ministry of Education has confirmed that Gloriavale School is under review by the Education Review Office (ERO). It follows a ruling by the Employment Court last week that six women, who lived in the Gloriavale Christian community, were employees and not community volunteers while working there. Judge Inglis said members of the closed Christian community accepted girls were only provided an education to the extent it prepared them for life in the sect. As RNZ reports, Brian Henry, who represented the six Gloriavale leavers in the case, is questioning how the ERO reconciles those findings with “their report saying this is a good school?" Neither the Ministry of Education, the Labour Inspectorate nor ERO directly responded to questions from RNZ about whether they accepted Henry's assessment of the school “training slaves”.
Click and Collect
An in-depth profile of the prime minister (paywalled) from The Herald’s Audrey Young
Te Whatu Ora confirms data won’t be reported on emergency department wait times until the end of the year (paywalled, The Post)
Using the New Zealand Election Survey results from 2020 Henry Cooke does a deep dive into who the Act party’s supporters are (
)- looks at whether last week’s ban on the Hamilton to Auckland train service operating within the Auckland metro area was justified. The rail union says it isn’t.
Got some feedback about The Bulletin, or anything in the news? Get in touch with me at thebulletin@thespinoff.co.nz.
If you liked what you read today, share The Bulletin with friends, family and colleagues.
Naomi Arnold reports on how ketamine is offering hope to sufferers of severe mental illness. Shanti Mathias with everything you always wanted to know about potholes but were afraid to ask. Stewart Sowman-Lund goes in search of ‘Luxonmania’ at O Week. Tara Ward picks out this year’s top 10 dismissed ad complaints by the ASA. Danny Rood explains the difference between carbon neutral, zero emissions and net zero. Mad Chapman regrets to inform you that once again the Black Ferns merch store is offering virtually nothing for fans to buy.
Sporting snippets
Fan taking selfie causes crash on stage 15 of the Tour de France
The Australian Women’s football team, the Matildas, have released a collective statement calling out Fifa’s World Cup prizemoney gender gap
Kiwi sprinter Danielle Aitchison takes gold in the women’s 200m T36 at the Para Athletics World Championships
Hollywood has bigger problems than the strikes
A triptych of reads for you today that I ironically read while binge-watching The Diplomat over the long weekend. First is Brooke Barnes in the New York Times (gift link) on how the challenges facing the film and television industry extend well beyond the consequences of historic strike action by writers and actors. Chase that with Gwilym Mumford in The Guardian who describes the streaming model as “malfunctioning” for audiences, creatives and streaming companies. Finally, hop back to the NYT (gift link) for a look at how writers, actors, social media companies and news organisations are handling one of the big “existential” challenges of our time, generative artificial intelligence, and the rebellion building against AI companies scrapping the internet to feed the machine.
Thanks for the sad humour
The "Brooke Barnes in the New York Times" link is broken.